$749,900

beds

baths

half bath

2,349

square ft

5861 N Bay Ridge Ave

Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin 53217

Name: 5861 N Bay Ridge Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
Price: 749900 USD
Availability: InStock

New / MLS #1986864 / Single Family / Whitefish Bay

Listing information updated 11/6/2026 at 12:41pm

Come for the location, stay for the personality! Thoughtfully updated while preserving its original character, this home is full of personality, from wallpaper and color drenched rooms to beautiful hardwood floors, vintage charm and modern updates. The new front door sets the tone from the moment you arrive, with a design that carries throughout. Upstairs, the versatile pass-through room is currently used as a 4th bedroom but could easily become an office, nursery, gym or playroom. With 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths and inviting outdoor living space, there's room to live, gather and entertain. Ideally located in a sought after school district and within walking distance to Silver Spring and Richards Elementary. Character, color and charm come together beautifully in this one of a kind WFB home!

See it in person

Open House

1:00pm - 2:30pm Sunday, November 8th, 2026 11/8/26

{"@context":"https:\/\/schema.org","@type":"Event","name":"Open House at 5861 N Bay Ridge Ave","description":"An Open House at 5861 N Bay Ridge Ave","startDate":"2026-11-08T13:00:00-06:00","endDate":"2026-11-08T14:30:00-06:00","eventAttendanceMode":"https:\/\/schema.org\/OfflineEventAttendanceMode","eventStatus":"https:\/\/schema.org\/EventScheduled","location":{"@type":"Place","name":"5861 N Bay Ridge Ave","address":{"@type":"PostalAddress","streetAddress":"5861 N Bay Ridge Ave","addressLocality":"Whitefish Bay","postalCode":"53217","addressRegion":"Wisconsin","addressCountry":"US"}},"image":"https:\/\/resources.atproperties.com\/images\/MetroMLS\/01\/986\/864\/6aecc33f50041\/1.jpg","organizer":{"@type":"Organization","name":"","url":"https:\/\/www.atproperties.com\/1986864\/5861-n-bay-ridge-ave-whitefish-bay-wisconsin-53217-swi"},"offers":{"@type":"Offer","price":749900,"priceCurrency":"USD","availability":"http:\/\/schema.org\/InStock","url":"https:\/\/www.atproperties.com\/1986864\/5861-n-bay-ridge-ave-whitefish-bay-wisconsin-53217-swi","validFrom":"2026-11-07T16:54:12-06:00"},"performer":{"@type":"PerformingGroup","name":""}}

Full Features

Architecture Style:

Bungalow

Exterior Type:

Brick,Wood

Basement:

Full,Partially Finished

Bedrooms:

Cooling System:

Central Air

Heating System:

Natural Gas, Forced Air

Appliances:

Oven, Refrigerator, Disposal, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer, Dryer, Other

Main Level Primary Bedroom:

Fireplace:

Yes

Pool:

Age:

99 Years

Parking Type:

Electric Door Opener,Paved

Parking Spaces:

Garage:

Detached - 2 Car(s)

Room Count:

Square Feet:

2,349

Lot Size:

0.14 Acres

Acreage:

0.14

Internal Features:

Walk-In Closet(s), Vaulted Ceiling(s)

External Features:

Patio/Porch

Room Information

Living Room:

20 x 19 - Main

Dining Room:

13 x 11 - Main

Kitchen:

13 x 12 - Main

Primary Bedroom:

21 x 18 - Upper

2nd Bedroom:

12 x 12 - Main

3rd Bedroom:

12 x 12 - Main

Rec Room:

27 x 11 - Lower

Laundry:

12 x 11 - Lower

Other Room:

15 x 12 - Upper

Taxes & Assessments

Tax Amount:

$8,121

Tax Year:

2025

Location

Zip Code:

53217

City:

Whitefish Bay

County:

Milwaukee

Schools

School District(s):

Whitefish Bay

Elementary School:

N/A

Middle School:

Whitefish Bay

High School:

Whitefish Bay

Architecture Style:

Bungalow

Exterior Type:

Brick,Wood

Basement:

Full,Partially Finished

Bedrooms:

Cooling System:

Central Air

Heating System:

Natural Gas, Forced Air

Appliances:

Oven, Refrigerator, Disposal, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer, Dryer, Other

Main Level Primary Bedroom:

Fireplace:

Yes

Pool:

Age:

99 Years

Parking Type:

Electric Door Opener,Paved

Parking Spaces:

Garage:

Detached - 2 Car(s)

Room Count:

Square Feet:

2,349

Lot Size:

0.14 Acres

Acreage:

0.14

Internal Features:

Walk-In Closet(s), Vaulted Ceiling(s)

External Features:

Patio/Porch

Living Room:

20 x 19 - Main

Dining Room:

13 x 11 - Main

Kitchen:

13 x 12 - Main

Primary Bedroom:

21 x 18 - Upper

2nd Bedroom:

12 x 12 - Main

3rd Bedroom:

12 x 12 - Main

Rec Room:

27 x 11 - Lower

Laundry:

12 x 11 - Lower

Other Room:

15 x 12 - Upper

Tax Amount:

$8,121

Tax Year:

2025

Zip Code:

53217

City:

Whitefish Bay

County:

Milwaukee

School District(s):

Whitefish Bay

Elementary School:

N/A

Middle School:

Whitefish Bay

High School:

Whitefish Bay

Listing Office: Keller Williams Milwaukee North Shore

Listing Office Phone: 414.962.3605

Disclaimer: The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of Metro MLS. Copyright 2026 Multiple Listing Service, Inc. - All Rights Reserved. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than @properties are marked with the Broker Reciprocity thumbnail logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

5861 N Bay Ridge Ave

Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin 53217