5261 Carrollton Avenue

Indianapolis, Indiana 46220

5261 Carrollton Ave blends the timeless charm of an American Cottage exterior with the finishes, craftsmanship, and functionality of a modern luxury home. Fully updated and thoughtfully designed, this 4-bedroom residence offers soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, and a layout tailored for both everyday living and entertaining. The custom kitchen is anchored by striking Borgnini quartz surfaces, custom cabinetry, designer shelving, and elevated finishes throughout. Upstairs, a versatile loft creates the perfect space for a media room, office, or play area, while the finished basement adds over 900 square feet of additional living space ideal for recreation, fitness, a home office, or guest retreat. Storage and organization were thoughtfully considered with built-in shelving systems in every closet and a true "shut-the-door" mudroom tucked off the rear entry. The primary suite delivers a luxury retreat experience featuring a spacious walk-in closet, dual vanities, and custom Bedrosian tile selections. Borgnini quartz continues into the upstairs bathrooms, creating a cohesive high-end design aesthetic. Outside, enjoy the welcoming front porch, spacious covered rear porch, and detached one-car garage complete with an oversized storage loft above. Perfectly positioned in one of Meridian-Kessler's most desirable pockets, you are just steps from neighborhood favorites including Mama Carolla's, Fresh Market, and Twenty Tap. A rare opportunity to own a home that blends cottage character, modern updates, and exceptional livability in the heart of Midtown Indianapolis.